Dr. Toby Holt (D.Min, M.Div New Geneva Theological Seminary) is president of New Geneva, and has pastored churches in Wyoming, Georgia and (currently) Mississippi. Dr. Holt has served as a church planter (WY), and has taught apologetics and Christian worldview courses overseas. Prior to becoming New Geneva's third president, Dr. Holt served as a member of the board.

Before coming to New Geneva, Dr. House served as the academic editor for New Testament and Greek books for Hendrickson Publishers in Peabody, MA (a subsidiary of Christianbook.com), where he edited the Compact Greek-English Lexicon and the Analytical Lexicon of New Testament Greek. Dr. House has previously taught at Talbot School of Theology in La Mirada, CA, Fuller Theological Seminary in Pasadena, CA, and Zaporozhye Bible College in Zaporozhye, Ukraine, and has a 25-year history of pastoral experience, having served two pastorates in the Presbyterian Church in America in Southern California.

Dr. Aquila has over thirty years of pastoral experience, most recently serving for twelve years as senior pastor of Kendall Presbyterian Church in Miami, FL. Dr. Aquila has served as editor of the web magazine of the Presbyterian Church in America and, in 2006, served as Moderator of the Presbyterian Church in America General Assembly. For twenty four years, he served as President of New Geneva, before transitioning into an Emeritus role in the winter of 2025.